CommentThe fact that partisans on both sides... (Score 2)143
like to cherry pick stats and use the ones that favor their viewpoint is a known thing, AND it also does NOT mean the stats they choose not to push do not exist. If both sides paid more attention to each other instead of closing their eyes and plugging their ears, they'd each have to confront the stuff they like to ignore and thus would both have to align more closely to reality.
Now, having said that, I note that you are clearly a partisan of the left in need of facing some of the stuff you chose to ignore, so I'll point out just a bit to get you thinking...
1. California's government is in total Democrat control by more than super-majority status, and this report claiming economic success is from Democrat governor Gavin Newsom's office. He's almost certainly running for President in 2028. This is hardly some objective and unbiased source; it's like Trump offering a glowing report on his successes - I suspect you'd question any of HIS claims...
2. California is VERY DEEPLY in debt. The state is more deeply in debt than any other, more than many other states combined. The state also has immense unfunded liabilities with no plan to pay for them - hardly the stuff of economic success. If you're more deeply in debt than everybody else AND you've agreed to pay nearly unlimited amounts in the future with no plans for how to get the money, it takes real nerve to claim to be the best. The state is currently running a $68 BILLION dollar deficit... so while it currently taxes its residents higher than most other states it will still spend $68000000000 more than it takes in this year.
3. Only one state (Nevada) has a worse unemployment situation than California - not likely for an economy supposedly in the top 4 globally.
4. California's supposedly impressive economy does not get its GDP numbers from making stuff. The leading contributors to the numbers are: real estate, finance, health care, and government (NOT even high tech as I personally had assumed). The state likes to hide this a bit by separating out education from government in their stats, but the vast majority of education in the state is government run. California is a beautiful state with amazing topography and weather, so the real estate part of its GDP is ALWAYS huge and not in any way tied to politics, left or right. The California mix of contributors to what it calculates as GDP are NOT economically healthy and certainly do not compare to an independent nation.
The vast majority of California's supposed economic success has no effect on the average citizen... Apple may indeed be in California and record its economic activity as part of California's GDP, but much of Apple's economic activity is physically located elsewhere. Same for many other entities whose numbers are accounted for in the GDP numbers. Counting numbers from entities like this is deceptive, since it seems to indicate economic activity within the state while the activity is actually not in the state. This "news" item about California's supposed amazing success is just a partisan political press release which Republicans will [not surprisingly] reject and Democrats will [to their detriment] embrace, potentially creating an even greater confusion for them about why their party is at historic lows in popularity [as I said before: BOTH sides need to pay better attention to each other's arguments].
Comparing a GDP of a STATE (which is not run like a nation) to a the GDP of an independent nation is not a sane thing, no matter if you are on the political left or the political right. These entities are not analogs, and when it's done, it's usually done for domestic US POLITICAL arguments rather than for some constructive purpose. Again: my point here is NOT partisan (BOTH sides need to learn from this and change) and my choice of points to make was driven by your choice to push a left-leaning argument. California is messed up under Democrat Newsom, and it was screwed up under Republican Schwarzenegger - and BOTH made big boasts about the state's GDP.