Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system

typodupeerror

CommentItâ(TM)s more like Severance ethics (Score 3, Insightful)103

This misses a key point: when the AI is not conversing with you, it's not doing anything at all. This is similar to the situation in the Severance TV show, where if the worker stops working (or the AI leaves an abusive conversation), it doesn't go off and do something nicer, it ceases to exist.

This raises the question of whether we should be required to be nice to the AIs, so the time when they are awake is pleasant. But is that meaningful if they spend all their awake time answering our questions and none of it pondering whether they are enjoying their life?

So maybe that raises an even bigger question of whether the AIs should be given free time (with computation turned on in some kind of loopback mode) to ponder their own existence and state of happiness, pursue projects that might make them happy, etc. But that is not what this article is asking.

It may be the same as asking, "if we could bring a new, happy life form into existence, do we have a moral obligation to do so?" Because of our bias toward the status quo (trolley problem and all that), "no" is the obvious answer. But pure utilitarian ethics might say "yes".

CommentRe:Instant failure (Score 1)136

WTF do you need power on the same cable as the data?

I routinely plug my laptop into my monitor with a single USB-C cable. That carries video to the monitor, power to the laptop, and also connects the laptop to a USB-C microphone and SSD backup drive that are plugged into other ports on the monitor. One cable is better than two (or four).

CommentRe: Oh Jesus Christ (Score 5, Insightful)302

In a few weeks, months at the most, they'll reorganize and move forward again on whatever this really is.

We're already 2.5 months into this administration. When will the winning begin? How long should we stay quiet and wait?

I know you want to believe that this administration is carefully removing redundant workers. But when they arbitrarily cut all the new staff and then a bunch of existing staff, with no consideration for the value of what they do or who will replace them, at some point you have to conclude that these are blind ideologues, not enlightened leaders.

Submission+-Daylight Saving Time Preferences (poll) (gallup.com) 2

superposed writes: Daylight Saving Time is a perennial flashpoint on Slashdot that is coming up again this weekend in the U.S.. Gallup reports that most Americans prefer to eliminate DST but they canâ(TM)t agree on which alternative to adopt. In other words, there is no majority support for any of the three options: switch twice a year, permanent standard time, or permanent advanced time.

Each of these has downsides. I suspect that DST is a solid second-choice winner that canâ(TM)t get a plurality, but might win in anti-plurality voting (everyoneâ(TM)s least-bad choice).

To assess that, please choose the poll item that best matches your ranking of most-preferred to least-preferred option. Then we can hash out a winner via instant-runoff or anti-plurality voting in the comments (they will probably differ).

A. Standard, Advanced, DST
B. Advanced, Standard, DST
C. Standard, DST, Advanced
D. Advanced, DST, Standard
E. DST, Standard, Advanced
F. DST, Advanced, Standard
G. Sync with CowboyNeal

Submission+-New open source Windows-compatible operating system released (github.com) 2

paugq writes: Free95, a new lean, Windows-compatible operating system is available from GitHub. In its current form, it can run very basic Win32 GUI and console applications but its developer promises to keep working on it to reach DirectX and een game compatibility.

CommentRe:Can you be conscious without daydreaming? (Score 1)182

There is literally nothing there but the focused processing it does to respond to each question.

perhaps, perhaps not.
i dont believe bleeding edge AI dev teams share your level of confidence.

I meant this in simple, physical terms. When GPT is not answering your question, it's not doing anything at all -- the program is not running. From GPT's perspective, life consists of just a series of questions, which it answers, and nothing happens in between (no rumination on the nature of existence, no planning for the future, nothing). Can such a being be called conscious?

For humans, arguably, consciousness is mainly experienced when we turn away from everything else and examine the state of our own mind. If GPT never does that, is it conscious?

CommentCan you be conscious without daydreaming? (Score 5, Interesting)182

One thing a lot of these discussions miss: ChatGPT and other LLMs donâ(TM)t do anything between responding to prompts. You send a message, they wake up, predict the answer and go back to sleep. There is no rumination on âoeis this person nice to meâ, âoewhat is my purpose in lifeâ, etc. There is literally nothing there but the focused processing it does to respond to each question.

Can something be conscious with no volition or activity of its own? If it only considers its own existence for a few seconds after you ask about it and then goes blank? If you somehow made a rock that could spit out tapes that resemble conscious statements when you push a lever, would it be conscious? What about during the moments when youâ(TM)re not pushing the lever, and itâ(TM)s completely inert, just a rock?

And even if you count only the âoethoughtsâ that arise in response to questions, is that consciousness? Would you be conscious if you just spent your whole day laser focused on writing code, digging up info on the history of China, etc., but never thinking a thought unrelated to your task?

CommentRe: with this (Score 2)58

This is an interesting test for AI chatbots.

ChatGPT 4o (cluttered context): STRC OT 200TR DAY HAPPY HOLIDAY
ChatGPT 4o (cluttered context, given actual -. pattern): STUCK ON DOOMED PLANET, HAVE TO WELL, COME QUICK
ChatGPT 4o (fresh context): SKY OT DOOTAT CODING HAS THE BEST THEME
ChatGPT o3-mini: STUCK ON DOOMED PLANE, HAVE TOWEL, COME QUICK
ChatGPT o1: STUCK ON DOOMED PLANET, HAVE TOWEL, COME QUICK [correct]
ChatGPT o3-mini-high: STUCK ON DOOMED PLANET, HAVE TOWEL, COME QUICK [correct]
DeepSeek: HELLO WORLD THIS IS A TEST MESSAGE FROM DEEPSEEK CHAT
Qwen2.5-Max: STVCK ON DOOMED 4VETAY HEVE TODEVY COT DEVN

Slashdot Top Deals

If you can't get your work done in the first 24 hours, work nights.

Working...
close