CommentRe:I didn't believe it from the very beginning. (Score 1)12
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and this wasn't it. These researchers are always so quick to make these announcements in an attempt to justify or procure more government funds, and it's a competition to see who can lie the most. This is how we wind up with George Santos shit. These people can say anything they want, and because we have no way to ever get to these places to verify it, it's meaningless.
I didn't believe it either, but for less conspiratorial reasons.
90% of the hype came from the media, but a bit from the researchers as well.
But they did it for the same reason everyone else got excited. They're nerds who became astronomers because they're interested in thinks like life in space and it would be super cool if it's true.
The claim they These researchers are always so quick to make these announcements in an attempt to justify or procure more government funds doesn't make sense. The results getting debunked puts egg on their face, it makes new funding harder to get, not easier.